New trends within the longstanding criminal feud between Oracle and Google: a federal appeals courtroom has reversed the 2016 ruling that discovered Google‘s use of Oracle’s Java APIs in Android was once honest use. The dispute has been ongoing since 2010.

“The truth that Android is freed from fee does no longer make Google’s use of the Java API applications noncommercial,” this week’s ruling stated. In a commentary, Google stated it is “disillusioned” within the new choice, including that “This sort of ruling will make apps and on-line products and services dearer for customers.”

The guts of the problem is whether or not using Oracle’s Java APIs in the best way Android does—this is, unmodified and “for a similar goal and serve as as the unique in a competing platform,” consistent with the appeals courtroom—is “honest use,” or such use that does not necessitate permission or fee. This ruling says it isn’t. If the verdict stands, Google might be accountable for damages; Oracle was once in the past searching for $eight.eight billion.

Google is prone to ask the courtroom to rethink the verdict, Bloomberg says. After that, the next move can be to take the case to america Excellent Court docket. The Excellent Court docket had in the past made up our minds to not evaluation the case in 2014.